Concentrated Stock Strategies: The HOPES Framework

Andrew Chatham |
Company stock · Retirement planning

Concentrated Stock Strategies: The HOPES Framework

Five tools, one coordinated plan for your concentrated position.

The short answer

HOPES organizes five approaches to concentrated stock: hold strategically, options strategies, philanthropy, exchange funds, and sell with intent. For executives approaching retirement, the question is how these tools fit together around taxes, access to money, and single-company risk—not which one is universally best.

 

You have probably heard at least one financial representative in a Patagonia vest say that concentration builds wealth and diversification protects it. Hidden inside that finance-world shibboleth are two difficult questions: when should I make the switch to diversification, and how do I do it efficiently? Selling down a concentrated position may trigger a crushing tax bill. Holding becomes increasingly uncomfortable as retirement draws near and your recovery time from a drawdown shortens.

One framework we find useful for organizing this conversation is HOPES, developed by Morgan Stanley's Global Investment Committee. It groups the available strategies into five tools you can use in combination to reach your goals.

The Five Categories

Hold strategically

Options strategies

Philanthropy

Exchange funds

Sell with intent

H: Hold Strategically

Your current conditions may not be conducive to acting now, so you wait with purpose. Some common events that may merit holding are:

Retirement, which will drop you into a lower bracket

Anticipated unusual deductions or business losses that will offset gains

A lockup period

A step up in basis at death as part of your estate plan

Where it fits: Investors with a known event on the horizon that materially changes the tax math.

Tradeoffs: Every year you wait is another year of concentrated risk. To address this, holding is often paired with one of the protective strategies below.

O: Options Strategies

Options let you reshape the risk profile of the position without selling it. A protective put sets a floor under the stock, functioning something like insurance with a premium cost. A covered call generates income by selling away some of the upside. A collar combines the two, funding the put by selling the call, which can reduce or eliminate the out of pocket cost in exchange for capping your upside.

Where it fits: Investors who need downside protection now but have tax or timing reasons to delay a sale.

Tradeoffs: Options carry their own costs, require ongoing management, and bring tax complexity. They provide protection, but they are not tax neutral. Constructive sale and straddle rules also mean the structure matters and needs to be carefully considered.

P: Philanthropy

You may not consider yourself “charitably inclined”, but if someone were to set your total contributions to all charities over the last 5 years, I think the total number may surprise you. The problem isn't that people don't give, it's that the giving is scattered across many years and many small transactions.

Between the standard deduction and a new floor on deductible giving, steady and modest generosity gets screened out entirely. What we recommend is bringing forward 5 years of giving into a single tax year and contributing that amount in concentrated shares to a donor advised fund. This allows you to realize the large contribution in one year, then grant the money out on your normal schedule. The charities see no difference. You get to take a deduction for your giving and reduce the position without ever realizing the gain.

Note: a DAF grants only to qualified 501(c)(3) public charities, and you cannot receive anything of value in return.

For those with larger charitable goals, tools like a charitable remainder trust or a pooled income fund may be applicable.

Where it fits: Investors who give to registered charities.

Tradeoffs: The money is gone. Deduction limits apply based on AGI and asset type. Coordinate with your CPA before the gift, not after.

E: Exchange Funds

An exchange fund pools concentrated positions from many investors. You contribute your shares, receive an interest in a diversified partnership, and get instant diversification without realizing the gain.

The mechanics matter. After a seven year holding period, you can redeem your shares for a basket of holdings from the fund that will carry the gains from your original contribution. The gain is deferred, not erased.

Exchange funds are a complex topic and have strict rules that should be understood before utilizing. Most accept only qualified purchasers into the fund.

Where it fits: Investors with substantial low basis positions who want immediate diversification and do not require access to funds in the medium-term.

Tradeoffs: Capital is committed, fees run higher than an index fund, there is leveraged real estate in the fund, and you accept whatever basket the fund chooses to give you at redemption. Exit early and you generally get your original shares back plus a fee, which defeats the purpose.

S: Sell with Intent

Selling with intent means a plan rather than an impulse: phasing sales across tax years to stay under bracket or surtax thresholds, pairing them with losses harvested elsewhere, using a tax managed or long/short strategy to generate offsetting losses, or setting up a 10b5-1 plan if you are an insider.

Where it fits: Almost everyone, eventually. The other four tools mostly buy time, manage risk, or lower the cost of getting here.

Tradeoffs: Taxes are real and will not disappear. The goal is control over the timing and the rate, not avoidance.

Putting It Together

In practice we rarely see one strategy do all the work. Consider a hypothetical.

David is 58, a senior executive, and plans to retire at 61. Of his $6.5 million investable net worth, $4 million sits in his employer's stock with a basis of about $400,000. That is 62% riding on one company. He is in the top tax bracket and selling outright would result in a tax bill well over $800,000. Doing nothing leaves his retirement on a single ticker. He and his wife give about $30,000 a year in cash to their church.

Year one, protect the downside (O). A zero cost collar caps his downside while the rest of the plan is built, and no tax question has to be settled first.

Year one, fund the giving (P). He contributes $300,000 (representing 30% of his AGI) of his lowest basis shares to a donor advised fund. Ten years of giving, prepaid, with roughly $270,000 of gain that never gets taxed, deducted in a top bracket year.

Year one, diversify the core (E). As a qualified purchaser, he moves $1.5 million into an exchange fund. Single name risk on the largest block disappears without a taxable event. This amount represents what he wants to leave to his children as part of his estate plan. The holdings will be broadly diversified within the exchange fund until after his death. Then the assets can be pulled out and receive their step-up in basis.

Years one through three, sell deliberately (S). Roughly $250,000 a year, sized to stay inside his current bracket and paired with loss harvesting elsewhere. About $750,000 comes off at a controlled rate.

Year four forward, hold on purpose (H). Roughly $1.45 million remains heading into retirement, and the holding is now strategic. He sells it down across his first retirement years at a materially lower rate, rolling off the collar as the position shrinks.

By the time David retires, a position that was 62% of his net worth is closer to 20%, and he paid tax on a fraction of what a single sale would have triggered.

Hypothetical for illustration only. It does not represent an actual client, and results will differ with your own tax situation, basis, and goals.

The Bottom Line

Returning to the two questions I mentioned at the start, how do you know when you should diversify and how do you do it efficiently. You need a plan built with your goals in mind that thoughtfully uses the applicable tool(s) at each step along the way.

A few questions worth your consideration. What share of your investable net worth is in one position? What would the tax bill be if you sold half tomorrow? Are you funding charitable giving with cash that could come from shares instead? Are you comfortable with the level of company-specific risk your portfolio is exposed to?

If you are carrying a concentrated position and would like to create a plan using this framework, see the link below to reach out and schedule a free conversation with us.

Tracking - 1193947